I’ve been receiving nice feedback for the first part of this post, so I won’t hesitate to post a second one now, and more in the succeeding weeks. As I’ve mentioned, this will be a weekly post. Last week’s winner is Anthony Fedorov’s version of I Surrender, by just one vote! Thanks for those who participated and voted. Keep doing so for the next ones hehe!
This week, I will be featuring two Idols I love so much. Season 4 grand winner Carrie Underwood and 7th season’s Brooke White. Can I just say that I am a Carrie-holic haha, although I rooted for Bo then. Brooke’s such a darling and I believe she should have been the last girl standing during their season. Anyway, the song would be Love Is A Battlefield. Both ladies gave different renditions, so it’s up to you who you’d choose. Again, let me just repeat what I said on the previous post that this is just for fun and not to compare the two Idols. Thanks and enjoy!
First up, Carrie:
And now Brooke’s version:
Vote, vote, vote! 
Your Result
Edward Cullen. You are Edward Cullen. Charming and polite yet stubborn and overprotective, your desperately adorable crooked smile bears the weight of your inner pain and self-loathing. Your salvation lies in love -- though you won't admit it, you feel you can save your soul in the arms of your true love, Bella.
Carrie Underwood ’nuff said!
thanks Enzo!! u like Carrie din pala? hehehe..
i’ll go with Carrie Underwood’s Love Is A Battlefield. =D
seriously? nahirapan ako! Arrgghh.
But I chose Carrie! I love the vibrating rock voice!
ako na naman ang naiba!! hehe
i LOOOVE carrie, but i chose brooke’s version..
waaaah you knew i’d fall for this. my favorites from the respective seasons 4 and 7. i have to say i’d give this to brooke! one of my favorite performances. and gaaad, ang linis lang talaga!
ang magandang poll is midnight train to georgia by paris and jasmine and jesus take the wheel by gokey and lakisha. lakisha ako tho.
Czarovic, thanks for the vote! next week ulet ha?! hehehe…
Hey O! this is your bday poll hehe! thanks din sa pagvote lage, suki hahaha! Nahirapan ka ba? Cge, iisip din ako ng iba pang mahirap na pair sa mga susunod na posts ko… =)
Sash! I know we both love Carrie, but honestly I’d go for Brooke’s version too! For me, mas heartfelt yung performance nya… thanks for the vote & comment! =)
Kapatid na Arden! I knew you’d love this, at nagcomment ka na tlaga, unlike last week vote lang haha… thanks for the suggestions, I put them on the list na… watch for it na lang soon! =p
Brooke White….
Kasi mas kita mo yung essence ng “Music”, tapos parang ang lambing lambing
na ang lamig lamig the way na kinakanta nia yung music.
Yung kay Carrie kasi for me, parang wala eh, maingay, magulo…. vibrating rock daw nga sabi ni Oscar, saka sana dapat kinulayan nia ng itim yung mata nia at yung mga kuko nia tapos may bling bling sia para accord dun sa last part na ginawa nia na hinampas nia sa hangin yung mike bago matapos…..
Carrie, Carrie, C-A-R-R-I-E!
Brooke White! Absolutamente! haha..
uh-oh, im afraid this comment will be bias since im a self confessed Brooke White fan. but yeah, Originality (check!), Emotions (check!), and Control (check!)
i know Carrie’s performance came all flashy and loud, but like Cowell said, it’s about originality, and Brooke didnt fail to do that!
In a Randy Jackson persona, id say: “That’s a hot one right there! it’s the bomb, dawg!” haha…
Bert, katawa naman yung comment mo! hahaha.. di naman bagay kay Carrie yung rock chick image eh, Country girl sya forever hehe…
Thanks for the vote and comment, birthdaymate Ria!! where’s my pasalubong??!hahahaha!!
Hey there, Brazilian Romeo!! hehehe… thanks!! My vote goes to Brooke, too. Seriously. Although I’m a bigger Carrie fan. Anyway, I’ll keep you posted here on my weekly posts.. thanks again!!
id go for brooke’s version. she made it her own…sobrang clear ng lyrics & nandun ung emotion. waaaahhh…. na miss ko c brooke!!!!
xcess>i thot nung una kay jordin n battlefield kkantahin nla, kay pat benatar pla. haahaaa sensya na, syonga lng…
ayt cuz! til next time….
i hate u polding!i had a hard time choosing…but of course in the end….si carrie parin 4me…..
Love them both but I prefer Brooke’s rendition of this particular song!